• About Us
  • List Your Firm
  • Legal Awards
  • Contact Us
Login | My Posts
Lawyers In Malta - Maltese Legal Portal
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • Law Firms in Malta
  • About Malta
    • Maltas Legal System
    • Malta Economy Overview
    • Business in Malta
    • Live and do business in Malta
    • Citizenship & Residence in Malta
    • Real Estate in Malta
  • Publications
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Law Firms in Malta
  • About Malta
    • Maltas Legal System
    • Malta Economy Overview
    • Business in Malta
    • Live and do business in Malta
    • Citizenship & Residence in Malta
    • Real Estate in Malta
  • Publications
No Result
View All Result
Lawyers In Malta - Maltese Legal Portal
No Result
View All Result
Home Articles

Fixed-Term Contracts in the Public Sector: Compensation Beyond Stabilisation

Author: Andrea Sticca - WH Partners

by WHPARTNERS
November 17, 2026
in Articles
Reading Time: 5 mins read
Fixed-Term Contracts in the Public Sector
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Compensation for Abusive Fixed-Term Contracts in the Public Sector After Permanent Appointment

Permanent appointment in the public sector does not preclude the right to compensation for the abuse of successive fixed-term contracts. In Judgment no. 26566 of 10 October 2026, the Court of Cassation clarifies that compensation ranging from 4 to 24 months’ salary also applies to pending cases, provided that no final judgment has been handed down, and that permanent appointment may affect the calculation of the amount.

Permanent appointment and compensation: two forms of protection that can coexist 

Permanent appointment does not necessarily bring an end to litigation concerning the misuse of fixed-term contracts in the public sector. In Judgment No. 26566 of 10 October 2026, the Court of Cassation clarifies that, following the amendment to Article 36(5) of Legislative Decree No. 165 of 30 March 2001, the permanent appointment runs alongside the right to compensation without replacing it.

The decision has implications for staff management and the assessment of disputes: permanent appointment does not preclude the right to compensation for the previous abusive use of successive fixed-term contracts. If directly linked to the abuse, permanent appointment may be taken into account when quantifying the compensation, but it does not eliminate it.

The Court of Cassation also addresses the issue of temporal application. The rules introduced in 2024 apply to pending disputes, including cases referred back to lower courts, provided that the issue has not already become subject to a final and binding decision within the proceedings. It is therefore necessary to re-examine outstanding claims for compensation in the light of the new regulatory framework.

Fixed-term contracts in the public sector: the case and the ruling 

The dispute arose from the employment relationship between a female employee and the Municipality of Barcellona Pozzo di Gotto. Following a period of employment in socially useful work programmes,  the employee had entered into a part-time fixed-term contract, which was subsequently extended on several occasions. In 2006, her working hours were increased to 24 hours per week and the term of the contract was extended until 31 December 2011.

The employee had sought, among other things, a declaration that the fixed-term contract was unlawful and compensation for damages. Following an initial hearing before the Court of Cassation, the Court of Appeal of Messina, ruling on the case on remand, had declared that the claim for compensation had become moot: the employee’s subsequent permanent appointment by the municipality had remedied the abuse.

The Court of Cassation does not agree with this conclusion. The 2024 reform requires compensation to be awarded even where the worker has been granted a permanent appointment.

Compensation for fixed-term contracts following the reform 

Article 12 of Decree-Law No. 131 of 16 September 2024, converted into Law No. 166 of 14 November 2024, introduced into Article 36 specific provisions governing damages resulting from the abuse of a succession of fixed-term contracts or employment relationships.

The court must award compensation amounting to between four and twenty-four months’ worth of thesalary used as the basis for calculating severance pay. The amount depends on the seriousness of the breach, assessed in relation to the number of contracts and the total duration of the employment relationship. This is without prejudice to the employee’s right to prove greater damage.

The reform not only broadens the financial range of compensation but also expressly establishes the protection available and the criteria for determining its amount. The prerequisite remains abuse. The succession of contracts does not, by virtue of its mere existence, confer a right to compensation: the unlawfulness of the repeated practice must be assessed in the light of the applicable legislation.

Furthermore, the prohibition on the automatic creation of a permanent employment relationship as a consequence of a breach of mandatory provisions on recruitment or employment remains in force. The judgment’s reference to conversion as a measure accompanying compensation must be read in the context of a legitimate transition to permanent status; it does not introduce a general judicial conversion of public-sector employment relationships.

From Community-law damages to statutory protection 

To understand the scope of the ruling, it is necessary to consider the previous system. As set out in Judgment No. 5072 of 15 March 2016, the Joint Divisions had identified a form of protection capable of reconciling the prohibition on conversion with the European requirement to effectively sanction abuse.

The worker was exempt from proving damage up to an amount based on the compensation provided for in Article 32(5) of Law No. 183 of 4 November 2010, ranging from 2.5 to 12 months’ worth of their last actual total remuneration. This constituted what was known as ‘Community-law damages’, without prejudice to the possibility of proving further harm.

Within this framework, a line of case law had developed which recognised that permanent appointment had remedial effect, provided that the permanent appointment within the responsible public administration was a direct consequence of the abuse. It was not sufficient that the experience gained in previous employment relationships had merely facilitated the recruitment.

The 2024 reform expressly provides for compensation, without making it conditional on the failure to secure permanent employment. According to the Court of Cassation, permanent employment cannot therefore be regarded as an alternative to compensation, but rather as a measure that runs alongside it.

Permanent appointment: it affects the amount, not the entitlement 

Permanent appointment retains a role in determining the amount, within the legal limits, where it is directly linked to the abuse. The causal link therefore remains important, but its function changes: it serves to assess the amount, not to deny compensation in its entirety.

Consider, as a practical example, an employee hired on a permanent basis through a procedure reserved for temporary staff following an abusive succession of contracts. The administration cannot rely solely on the permanent appointment to rule out compensation; it may document the link between the procedure and the previous abuse so that the court takes this into account in determining the award.

The situation is different in the case of a post obtained through an open competition, where previous service merely worked in the candidate’s favour. The professional advantage gained from previous experience does not, in itself, establish the direct link between the permanent appointment and the abuse required by the Court’s reasoning. In neither of these examples does the judgment provide for a predetermined reduction or a mathematical formula for the calculation.

Pending cases: the limits of res judicata 

The new regime also applies where the contracts and the abuse predate the reform, provided the dispute over compensation is still pending. The Court observes that the law has expressly regulated an area previously governed by case law, without providing for any contrary transitional provisions.

The limitation is the existence of an issue that has become res judicata within the proceedings. The ruling does not authorise the reopening of issues that have already been definitively decided and does not introduce a general review of settlements that have already been finalised. In order to assess a pending case, it is necessary to ascertain which points are still in dispute and which have become final.

Compensation beyond permanent appointment 

The ruling restores significance to the history of the employment relationship even after permanent appointment. The duration of precarious employment, the succession of contracts and the link between abuse and permanent appointment all contribute to determining the amount of compensation, without permanent appointment alone being able to settle the issue of compensation.

The stability thus acquired represents one element of the assessment rather than bringing the matter to an end. . The new framework makes it possible to recognise the value of permanent employment whilst, at the same time, maintaining a financial remedy for the abuse: the end of precarious employment does not deprive the period during which the employment relationship was unlawfully renewed of protection.

Previous Post

Gambling Regulation in Malta and the Rise of Hybrid Products: DeFi, GameFi and Prediction Markets

Next Post

Malta Launches €25.8 Million Tender for Gozo Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrade

Next Post
Tender for Gozo Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrade

Malta Launches €25.8 Million Tender for Gozo Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrade

Find a Lawyer

List you Law firm

Want to be a part of our
Law Directory? 

Submit Interest

Popular Tags

AML/CFT regime Anti-money laundering Artificial Intelligence Aviation Banking and Finance Blockchain Business Citizenship by Investment in Malta Commercial Contracts competition Consumer Protection Corporate Law Criminal Law Digital Transformation Economy Employment Law EU Family Law Financial Services fintech Funds GDPR Human Rights iGaming Malta Immigration Insurance Law Intellectual Property Investments Litigation and Arbitration Malta Permanent Residency Program Public Law Real estate in Malta Shipping and Maritime Malta Tax Law Trademarks Trusts Virtual Financial Assets

A Premium Legal Portal Connecting Lawyers with Clients

Facebook Instagram Linkedin Xing

USEFUL LINKS

Contact Us
Terms & Conditions
Careers at Sedinvest
Advocates in Malta

USEFUL LINKS

Chamber of Advocates
Search for Lawyers in Malta
Why Lawyers in Malta
Malta Lawyers
Lawyers in Malta

AFFILIATE SITES

logo250-white
accountants-logo-tr-1

© 2026 Lawyers in Malta. All Rights Reserved.

Developed by Wizzweb

No Result
View All Result
  • Law Firms in Malta
  • About Malta
    • Maltas Legal System
    • Malta Economy Overview
    • Business in Malta
    • Live and do business in Malta
  • Publications
  • About Us
  • List Your Firm

© 2024 Lawyers in Malta - All rights Reserved.